You check your course sales on Monday morning, hoping your evergreen webinar finally did its job.
It didn’t.
Then you open Instagram, and the first post you see is a coach celebrating her sold-out program… all thanks to her brand-new low-ticket funnel.
Because as she puts it…. “Lead magnets only bring in freebie seekers”.
So naturally, you think, “That’s it, my webinar isn’t working. I clearly need a low-ticket offer funnel”.
Yeah, I get it. Being an online business owner often means constantly being online. Which means you’re susceptible to all the *new and shiny* marketing strategies that people are always shouting about.
And that can make you question your own strategy when it’s not working as well as you’d like it to.
But what if the reason you’re not making enough sales has nothing to do with your marketing strategy?
After working with hundreds of online coaches, I’ve found that when an offer isn’t selling consistently, it’s usually not the marketing strategy.
More often than not, the real problem is something further upstream.
And until you identify and fix that problem, switching strategies is just going to keep you buried in busy work for the next month when you could have been finding the real problem.
In this post, I’m going to show you the three things I look at when an offer isn’t selling, why constantly changing your marketing strategy could be making things worse, and how to figure out what actually needs fixing.
Why it’s so easy to believe you need a new marketing strategy
If you’ve spent any time in the online coaching space, you’ll know there’s no shortage of people telling you they’ve found the new (and best) way to get clients.
One minute, everyone’s telling you that webinars are the best way to sell your course.
Next, it’s low-ticket offers.
Then it’s challenges, evergreen funnels, or some shiny new AI-powered tool that promises to do all the hard work for you.
And of course, everyone has the results to prove that THEIR way works.
So when your current strategy isn’t bringing in the sales you want, it’s easy to look at what everyone else is doing and wonder what you’re missing.
Especially when you see other coaches talking about their amazing results.
And before you know it, you’re knee-deep in another course, rebuilding your funnel, creating new content, and learning a completely different way to market your offer.
But the truth is, most marketing strategies work.
Webinars, email marketing, challenges and evergreen funnels all actually work… when you stick with them long enough.
The real question is whether the offer you’re selling, and the way you’re talking about it, makes people want to buy.
Because if it doesn’t, changing how you get in front of people won’t magically fix that.
The problem with constantly changing your marketing strategy
Here’s a quick real-world scenario I see all the time:
A coach builds a funnel to sell her signature program.
She spends weeks creating the webinar, writing the emails, building the sales page, and getting everything connected.
She launches it… and she only gets 2 sales.
Now, instead of checking the data and working out what her conversion rate was, she thinks, “Oh no, it didn’t work.”
She already had a small doubt in her mind about something in the funnel… maybe she secretly thinks webinars don’t actually work anymore (probably something she heard online already).
And she decides this is never going to work and starts looking for something else.
And suddenly she’s back in creation mode.
A brand-new strategy, with a new funnel to build and a whole new set of emails and content to write.
Another few months go by, and she’s right back where she started.
Sound familiar?
The problem with this approach is that you never give yourself the opportunity to actually make it work.
Because the truth is, most funnels don’t actually convert from day 1.
Most experienced business owners WORK at their funnels and only get it right on iteration number 5… or even number 20.
The difference is, because they’ve done this so many times, they KNOW it’s part of the process.
Test, refine, repeat.
They all do it… they just dont talk about how much work it takes.
And it probably feels like less work for them because they’re used to it, they build in time for testing, and they iterate quickly because its an expectation that they have to.
But if you’re constantly throwing everything out and starting again, you never get to that stage.
You’re spending all your time creating instead of improving.
And not only is that exhausting, but it’s also taking time away from the work that could actually help you make more sales.
So instead of spending the next three months building another brand-new funnel, let’s look at what’s actually going wrong.
3 reasons your offer isn’t selling consistently (that have nothing to do with your marketing strategy)
When I work with coaches whose courses, memberships, or group programs aren’t selling the way they want them to, there are three things I look at first.
And more often than not, one or more of these is the real reason they’re struggling to make sales.
1. People don’t understand what your offer actually does
This is one of the most common problems I see.
You’re so close to your offer that you know exactly how valuable it is.
You know what’s inside it, how much work you’ve put into it, and how much it can help your clients.
But when someone lands on your sales page or reads an email about your program, they can’t immediately figure out what it’s going to do for them.
I actually see this a lot with memberships; people think their ideal client needs ongoing support so they create a membership and make the entire sales page about “getting support”.
But support isn’t a RESULT on its own.
So instead of talking about support, they actually need to talk about the result that support is going to get them.
Or they could be using a lot of jargon, which i see in the spiritual space all the time.
Coaches talking about “awakening the divine feminine”, “raising their vibrations”, “aligning with their highest selves”.
And yes, some of these phrases might make perfect sense to your ideal clients. They might even use them themselves.
But just because someone understands the language you’re using doesn’t mean the result is clear enough to actually make them buy your program.
When people are deciding whether to spend money on something, they often need a level of clarity they don’t necessarily need when they’re just consuming your content or signing up for a freebie.
And if they can’t see what they’re actually paying for, they’re going to have a hard time justifying the investment.
And that’s not something a new marketing strategy is going to fix.
You could send thousands more people to your sales page, but if they still can’t understand why they should buy, you’re likely to end up with the same problem.
2. You’re selling a result your ideal client doesn’t actually want
This one is a little trickier.
Because sometimes the result you’re promising is something your ideal client genuinely needs.
But that doesn’t mean it’s something she actually wants to buy.
Here’s another example to demonstrate:
Imagine you’re a weight loss coach.
You’ve worked with enough women to know that one of the biggest reasons they struggle to lose weight is that they constantly put everyone else’s needs ahead of their own.
They don’t prioritise themselves, which means they don’t make time to exercise or prepare healthy meals.
So you create a program focused on changing their mindset and learning to put themselves first.
And you start marketing it as a weight loss program that helps women with their mindset.
The problem is your ideal client doesn’t think she has a mindset problem.
She thinks she has a time problem.
She’s busy. She’s juggling work, kids, and everything else. And she just wants to know how to fit exercise into her already packed schedule.
So when she sees your mindset program, she scrolls straight past it.
Because in her mind, she doesn’t need what you’re selling.
She wants quicker workouts that fit into her day.
You’re selling her how to prioritise herself.
If you want her to buy, you either need to explain WHY mindset is the answer (this is the harder route because your content will have to do a lot of education and that makes buying take longer)….
Or you could take the easier route and position your offer around the problem she already knows she has.
In this case, helping her find time to exercise and eat well, even with her busy schedule.
You can still include all the mindset work you know she needs inside your program. In fact, that might be the very thing that makes your approach so effective.
But instead of trying to convince her she needs to fix her mindset before she’ll buy, you’re selling her a solution to a problem she’s already looking to solve.
This is why understanding your ideal client is about so much more than knowing her age, income, or what she does for a living.
You need to understand how she sees her problem.
What does she think is stopping her from getting the result she wants?
What has she already tried?
What is she actively looking for help with?
Because when your messaging speaks to the problem your ideal client already wants to solve, selling becomes much easier.
3. People can’t see how your offer is different from everything else out there
Ok, let’s say you’ve got all those pieces already, but you’re still not selling as many spots in your program as you’d like to….
The next thing I’d look at is whether people can see what makes your program different.
Because your ideal client probably has lots of options.
If you’re selling a business coaching program, there are probably hundreds of other coaches promising to help her do exactly the same thing you are.
The same with weight loss.
And if everyone is making the same promises, using the same language, and talking about the same benefits, why should she choose you?
This is where I would add a unique angle or mechanism to help you stand out.
You need to give people a reason to believe your approach is different from everything else they’ve already seen or tried.
This could be a different way of solving the problem, something that other coaches in your space have overlooked.
Or maybe your program helps people get the result they want without having to do something they really don’t want to do.
Whatever it is, you need to make that difference clear.
Because if your messaging sounds exactly like everyone else’s, your ideal client has no way to choose between you and everyone else.
And when people can’t see how you’re different, they’re much more likely to keep looking, compare you on price, or put off making a decision altogether.
Again, that’s a positioning and messaging problem, not a funnel problem.
So what should you do instead of changing your marketing strategy?
The first thing I’d recommend is to stop rebuilding everything and start looking at what you already have.
Because the data you have from your current funnel can give you some pretty useful clues about where things are going wrong.
For example, let’s say you’re getting plenty of people to your sales page, but hardly anyone is buying.
That tells us people are interested enough to click through, but something isn’t convincing them to take the next step.
So that tells me your emails are doing their job. They got people to click through.
Which means the problem is more likely on the sales page… maybe the result isn’t clear enough, or people can’t see how your program is different.
Or if you’re sending emails to your list, but hardly anyone is clicking through to find out more about your program.
That’s a different problem.
And that often does point to messaging because you haven’t given people a good enough reason to click through in the first place.
The point is, these two situations require different fixes.
And neither one means you need a new marketing strategy.
Of course, your numbers don’t always give you a definitive reason something isn’t working.
Which is why its always helpful to have an expert take a look at everything for you.
Find the leak before you try to fix the funnel
This is exactly how I approach things when I work with clients inside Designed To Scale.
We start by looking at how you’ve been selling your offer.
We look at the funnel, the conversion rates, the email clicks, the sales page, and the messaging you’re using.
And I work out where the biggest improvements can be made.
After 1000+ funnel reviews, I can normally tell within minutes what needs to change and why.
From there, I put together a prioritised list of changes, starting with the ones that will make the biggest difference fastest.
Then we work through them one by one.
Rather than spending months building something completely new, we focus on improving what’s already there.
And sometimes, the change that makes the biggest difference is much smaller than you’d expect.
How one small change doubled a client’s webinar revenue
One of my recent clients came to me after spending three months creating a low-ticket offer funnel that was supposed to lead people into her signature program.
It didnt end up converting, and she realized she’d wasted three months building a funnel she didn’t even want.
What she actually wanted was to sell her signature program.
So instead of going back to the drawing board, we looked at the way she was currently selling her signature program – a webinar.
When I looked at her numbers, I could see that her webinar conversion rate was really good.
The people who showed up were buying.
But her show-up rate was terrible.
So the problem wasn’t necessarily her offer, her webinar content, or the way she was selling.
The problem was getting people to attend in the first place.
After a couple of tests, we realized that her webinar timing was likely a big part of the problem.
She was running her webinar at 9am on a Monday morning… for business owners.
Think about that for a second.
It’s Monday morning. They’ve been off all weekend, they’ve got a million things to catch up on, and they’re trying to get their week started.
Sitting through a webinar probably isn’t at the top of their priority list.
So we changed the webinar time to Thursday at 11am.
And guess what happened? Her show-up rate doubled.
Her conversion rate stayed the same, but because twice as many people were attending live, she made twice as much revenue from the same webinar.
From one change.
No new funnel or marketing strategy. And no spending another three months creating something from scratch.
We simply looked at what was happening, identified the biggest problem, and tested a change.
Now, not every conversion problem is going to have such a simple fix.
But this is a perfect example of why it’s so important to understand what’s actually going wrong before you decide you need to change everything.
But what if my marketing strategy used to work, and now it doesn’t?
Fair enough. A lot has changed in the online space over the last few years.
With AI making it easier and faster than ever to create content, courses, and marketing materials, the online coaching space has become much more competitive.
And at the same time, we’re seeing what people are describing as a trust recession.
People are more sceptical about the promises they see online.
They’ve seen plenty of big claims, bought programs that haven’t delivered what they hoped for, and become more cautious about where they spend their money.
Which means some of the things that used to work aren’t getting the same results anymore.
But once again, from what ive seen, it’s not normally the strategy that’s stopped working.
It’s that the messaging and positioning that used to be good enough just aren’t good enough anymore.
A few years ago, you might have been able to get away with an offer that was a little vague or sounded similar to other offers on the market.
There was less competition, so it was easier to get attention.
Now, your ideal clients have more options than ever.
You need to work a bit harder at showing them why your offer is different (and better), and why they should trust you.
So yes, the online space has changed.
And your marketing probably needs to evolve with it.
But there’s a big difference between refining your messaging to stay relevant and throwing out your entire marketing strategy because your sales have slowed down.
I’ve written a separate blog post about how AI is changing the online coaching space and what that means for selling your offers.
Before you build another funnel, figure out what’s actually broken
If there’s one thing I want you to take away from this post, it’s this:
Inconsistent sales don’t automatically mean you need to throw out your entire marketing strategy.
Yes, sometimes your strategy really isn’t the right fit for your business.
But I can tell you from experience, it’s rarely the thing that will make the biggest difference to SALES (unless it’s just not a good fit for you as a person).
More often, the problem is that people don’t understand what your offer does, you’re selling a result they don’t actually want, or they can’t see how your program is different from other options.
And until you fix those things, you could keep changing your marketing strategy until you’re blue in the face and still end up with the same disappointing results.
So before you sign up for another course, rebuild your funnel, or start creating a completely new way to sell your program, take a look at what you’ve already got.
Look at your numbers. Find out where people are dropping off. Question whether your messaging is connecting with what your ideal clients actually want.
And start testing changes.
That way, in a few months time, instead of a brand new funnel that you have to start testing, you could have a marketing system that you understand well enough to know what to improve when your results start slipping.
Want help figuring out why your offer isn’t selling?
If you’ve got a course, group program, or membership that isn’t bringing in the sales you want, I’d love to help.
Inside Designed To Scale, I’ll be your personal strategist for 3 months, working alongside you to double your program sales, without having to triple the size of your audience.
We’ll start by looking at your current offer, messaging, and marketing data to identify where you’re losing the most buyers.
Then I’ll put together a clear, prioritised plan of what needs to change.
And over the next three months, we’ll work through those changes together, testing and refining your offer and messaging to improve sales.
So instead of spending another few months building a funnel you’re not even sure you need, you can focus on getting more people to buy the program you’ve already created.
Ready to stop rebuilding your marketing and start improving your sales?